Should a mini-split be repaired or replaced? Start with the condition of the ductless mini-split, the specific problem that has actually been confirmed, recent repair history, comfort performance and the completeness of each proposed scope. Do not let equipment age, a single symptom or a sales label decide the result by itself; a repair quote and a replacement quote must describe different work clearly enough to compare.
Climate load, utility programs, permit and efficiency requirements, labor access, disposal rules, and product support vary by location, so the better choice depends on verified local proposals rather than a national cutoff. Collect the model and serial information, service history, recurring symptoms, zone performance, energy-use trend, noise changes, and visible installation condition rather than deciding from equipment age alone. A repairable control, drain, or airflow issue is a different decision from extensive sealed-system damage, unavailable compatible parts, repeated failures, or a design that never served the rooms well. A contractor can document the present fault, remaining system condition, parts compatibility, refrigerant considerations, load and zoning needs, and whether the existing line set, electrical supply, and drains suit a replacement. Ask for repair and replacement options in comparable written scopes that identify diagnostics, equipment, labor, permits, commissioning, warranty terms, exclusions, and what happens to existing indoor heads and controls.