The project is described as like-for-like replacement
Give the authority the actual scope rather than relying on the phrase like-for-like. State what material will be removed, what will remain and whether trim, flashing or backing will change. Request a written permit or exemption determination when available. A contractor’s experience at a different address is useful context, not confirmation of the rules for this property.
Notice next: Prepare a short scope description and obtain the responsible building department’s response before work begins.